Raymond Tooth – Discovery Assessment Invalid says Court of Appeal


Andy Wood

Andy is a practical, creative tax adviser who assists a variety of clients in achieving their personal and commercial objectives in the most tax efficient manner.

Raymond Tooth – Discovery Assessment is Invalid says Court of Appeal

Background – Tooth v. HMRC

In the case of Raymond Tooth v HMRC, Mr Tooth had participated in a tax planning arrangement scheme. Details of this scheme are perhaps not relevant but its aim was to reduce his income tax liability for the tax year 2007/08 by creating a loss in 2008/09 and carrying it back.

He filed his tax return for 2007/08 including the scheme-based loss entering the losses on his partnership pages and with a white space disclosure that the loss being claimed was an employment loss rather than a partnership one.

Assuming the tax return is filed on time, HMRC is allowed to open an enquiry:

  • Under TMA, s9A: 12 months after the return is filed;
  • Schedule 1A of TMA: into a claim which is not included within a return.

HMRC informed the taxpayer in August 2009 that it had begun an enquiry (under Schedule 1A)  into the loss claim.

Mr Tooth disputed the ability HMRC’s powers to investigate this claim. As the Cotter case was to be heard in the Supreme Court, all parties waited for this decision with bated breath.

Following the Cotter decision, HMRC re-stated its view that the loss claims were disallowed.

Unsurprisingly, Mr Tooth maintained his view that HMRC’s enquiries were invalid.

HMRC issued a discovery assessment in October 2014. This claimed that the tax return was inaccurate and that the inaccuracies were deliberate in nature. The claims of ‘deliberate behaviour’ was important as this provides for a 20 year time limit for raising the assessment.

Raymond Tooth appealed this assessment to the tribunal.

Tribunal / CourtDecision
First Tier Tribunal (“FTT”)Taxpayer appeal was allowed

Taxpayer had argued that:

·      there was no ‘discovery’; and

·      the assessment was out of time any way as there was no deliberate inaccuracy

The FTT accepted that HMRC had made a discovery but that the assessment was out of time as there was no deliberate conduct

Upper Tier Tribunal (“UTT”)HMRC’s appeal was dismissed

UTT held there was no inaccuracy in the return as the taxpayer had given full disclosure. In any event, if there was an inaccuracy, there was no deliberate conduct – as had taken steps to draw HMRC’s attention to so was out for time.

The UTT also provided its view on whether there discovery was made in 2009 – in other words, the time at which HMRC knew all the facts and it had first disputed the return.  The UTT concluded that this discovery had become “stale” by October 2014 when HMRC raised the discovery assessment.

Court of AppealHMRC’s new appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal (“CoA”).

The CoA considered two main issues:

(1)   was there a discovery; and

(2)   If there was, had Mr Tooth’s inaccuracies been brought about by deliberate conduct?

In relation to the first point, the CoA stated that HMRC must have newly discovered that there was an insufficiency of tax. HMRC cannot simply find a new reason for disputing the adequacy of the assessment. In sum, HMRC had not established that there had been a discovery and therefore the raising of the discovery assessment was invalid.

In relation to the second point, the CoA agreed that there was both an inaccuracy and that the inaccuracy was deliberate.

If you receive a letter from HMRC where they say they are raising a discovery assessment then you must take action immediately. In the first instance you may look at appeal this discovery assessment and normally the time limit for doing so to HMRC is 30 days. Late appeals may be accepted by HMRC but, if not, you will need to appeal to the First Tier Tribunal.

We would recommend that if you receive such an assessment from HMRC that you speak to a specialist adviser without delay.

For more articles on discovery assessment please visit our signpost document.

If you, or your clients, have received a discovery assessment or have any queries about discovery assessment, then please do not hesitate to get in touch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.